Insights
Evidence over policy: what regulators ask to see
Why written policies are only the start, and the records that show your systems work.
DSA
OSA
Read Time :
3 min read
Why written policies are only the start, and the records that show your systems work. Regulators judge evidence. A policy says what you intend to do. Evidence shows what you actually do. Both the DSA and the Online Safety Act are written so that the second matters. The law asks for records, not only rules· Online Safety Act section 23. You must keep written records of every risk assessment, including how you did it and what you found. You must also record the measures you take to meet your duties. Read section 23. · DSA Article 17. Each statement of reasons must state the facts relied on, the ground, whether automation was used and the redress options. Read the DSA. · DSA Article 24(5). Online platforms must submit decisions and statements of reasons to the Commission's Transparency Database. · DSA Article 15. Intermediary services, other than exempt micro and small enterprises, publish content moderation reports at least once a year. Each of these creates a trail. If the trail is missing or does not match the policy, the policy will not help you. Where gaps usually appear· Policy and practice drift. The terms say one thing and moderators follow an older guide. · No reasoning on record. A decision was made, but nobody wrote down why, or what was rejected. · Untested controls. An age check or filter is live, but nobody measured whether it works. · Scattered evidence. Logs sit in one tool, decisions in chat, test results in a laptop folder. What good evidence looks like· Dated. You can show what was true on a given day. · Linked. Each record points to the duty it supports. · Owned. Someone is named as responsible for keeping it current. · Reviewable. An outsider can follow the reasoning without a meeting. · Repeatable. It is produced by the process, not created after a request arrives. Start smallPick one duty. Find the policy. Then find three pieces of evidence that show it works in practice. If you cannot, that is your first gap. Our free templates help: the DSA Statement of Reasons Template and the Age Assurance Decision Record. To find which duties apply first, run the EU and UK Platform Duty Screener. Get a view based on your evidenceBook a free 30 minute consultation with Ethrac. We will look at your service and tell you where your evidence is thin. Schedule a free consultation. This article is general information, not legal advice. |


